IN THE FORUMS >> VIEWS REPLIES  
  ■  Lias Recalled 2358 97  
  ■  Trade Deadline discussion/announcements 7943 517  
  ■  Game 59: New York Rangers @ Carolina Hurricanes... 580 129  
  ■  Game 58: New York Rangers @ Pittsburgh Penguins... 720 170  
  ■  What If? 195 4  
  ■  Game 57: New York Rangers @ Buffalo Sabres 7 PM... 552 57  
  ■  Game 56: New York Rangers @ Winnipeg Jets 2/12... 1133 162  
OTG POLL

What do you think of the Rangers season so far?

Quite surprised
Modestly surprised
As expected
Worse than expected
Terrible

Previous Polls
 INJURY REPORT
Vladislav Namestnikov 12/14
Expected to be in the line-up tonight
 
Fredrik Claesson 1/16
Will be out until February with a right shoulder injury
 
Neal Pionk 1/16
Will be out of the line-up until after the all-star break
 
Kevin Hayes 1/16
Could be back in the line-up as soon as Thursday
 
  MORE INJURY NEWS...
SEPTEMBER 24TH, 2014
CAPTION THIS
Read the submissions so far and see if you can come up with the best caption for today's photo

Best Of:
2014-15 ~ 2013-14
2012-13 ~ 2011-12
2010-11 ~ 2009-10

RUMOR MILL

Tuesday - October 25th

Either Josh Jooris (New York Daily News) or Dylan McIlrath are likely to find themselves on waivers when Pavel Buchnevich returns from back spasms.

The team is expected to cut the roster down to 22 players, and as such one of the two will need to be either moved or sent down.

  MORE RUMORS...

Question Of The Day

September 29th, 2017

How many rostered players were on the ice for opening night 2016-17

Answer...
  BIRTHDAYS

Greg Holst - 1954
Larry Melnyk - 1960
Dane Byers - 1986
Evgeny Grachev - 1990

  SEARCH BIRTHDAYS
  RANDOM RANGER

JIM DOREY
(1971-1972)
  Born: Aug 17 - 1947  
  Pos: Defense  
  GP: 1  
  G: 0  
  A: 0  
  Pts: 0  
  PIMs: 0  
 
Marian Gaborik came out in support of Crosby's call for eliminating head shots

Coming To A Head
Posted by Toby Ivey ≡ 11:56:53 AM - September 9, 2011

Eliminate all head shots from the NHL.  Sounds like a worthy endeavor, and even something that can be achieved with relatively little effort given the number of concussions to some of the premier offensive players like Sidney Crosby, Brad Richards, Marian Gaborik and Marc Savard among others.  But as the saying goes, the road to hell is paved with good intentions.

Perhaps the best example in recent times is the instigator rule, added in 1992.  The rule was introduced to help protect players from being jumped by an opponent when they weren't prepared.  It didn't eliminate fighting altogether - it does still allow willing combatants to square off - but it has to some extent reduced the violence in the sport.

It also opened up a window of opportunity for the "agitator" role.  Typically an undersized forward who has no problem crossing the line, and in many cases contributing to the very problem that Sidney Crosby and other leading players are now coming out against.

Matt Cooke, Raffe Torres, Vaclav Varada, Darcy Tucker, Ryan Hollweg, Patrick Kaleta and even Sean Avery are all modern day examples of this role to a more or lesser degree.  Most are disliked by the majority of their opponents, but they have carved out a role in the NHL.

Ultimately it was the instigator rule that helped these players reach their prominence, and it's the lack of accountability that has enabled them to continue to wreak havoc in the league.

That's not to say the instigator rule couldn't have worked.  The issue is really in the enforcement of the existing rules, and the ability to pose increasingly stiffer penalties, than the relatively soft ones that are now in place.  Perhaps instead of giving a handful of games here and there, a player faced a 20 or 40 game suspension, then they might think twice about crossing the line.

Last year the league introduced the blind-side hit clause to the interference rule.  The goal was to prevent players from being hit when they weren't prepared for the contact.  The result this past season was a series of cases that ultimately cost Colin Campbell his job as the league's enforcer.  The task at hand - to evaluate comparatively whether a hit was good or not - was ultimately too subjective, and put the league on the defensive more often than not.

The issue is that there is no way to objectively measure what is legal and illegal.  All hits become judgement calls, and there will almost always be someone who has grounds for disagreeing with the call.  The media, internet pundits and, even the fans themselves have the capability of undermining the credibility of those in charge, simply by disagreeing - albeit vociferously.

The incoming league discipline committee, headed up by Brendan Shanahan, is only all to aware of these issues.  His changes to the process - including public explanations for why a penalty was or was not implemented - is intended to address some of these concerns, and yet there's a good chance it simply increases the level of critiquing.  Perhaps the only mitigating factor will be that Shanahan is likely to get a good deal more respect than his predecessor.

If the league is to embrace Crosby's call to eliminate head shots, then they'll be faced with the challenge of putting in a set of rules that can work in the majority of situations.  It'll then be up to the referees to enforce them.

How do you take into account the height difference between players for instance.  Would a player like Mats Zuccarello benefit, while the likes of Zdeno Chara and Brian Boyle suffer, in much the same way as Eric Lindros would get called for interference penalties when players ran into him and bounced off?

What about players who are falling, or leaning over, or for that matter incidental contact?  In the case of high sticking, a player can be called when their opponent skates into their stick, could a similar situation happen with head shots?

We're still at the discussion phase of this proposed rule change, and there's no guarantee anything will get done at this point.  With that said, it does appear only a matter of time before some form of adjustment is made - later if not sooner.

At that point we'll likely experience the same sort of uneven enforcement of the rules that is common when a new subjective judgement is added to the referee's responsibilities.  While I can respect the players' calls for eliminating head shots, I have to wonder whether it might be yet another step on the road to reducing the level of excitement of the game.



Profile of the Author:
Has been an active follower of the New York Rangers since the 1996-97 season. Began OutsideTheGarden.com in 2001, and has continued to collect data and provide analysis on the team through to the current day.

 Additional stories from Toby Ivey:


YOUR COMMENTS

 
February 19th, 2019
RBC CENTER
  1 2 3 T
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
7:00pm -
Preview Game Thread
  HEADLINES
young-talent-continues-to-make-...
- The Athletic 11/7

Rangers rookie showed his worth...
- New York Post 11/7

What Rangers Lack In Skill, The...
- WFAN 11/7

Brady Skjei's finish makes up f...
- New York Newsday 10/12

Brett Howden is starting to sho...
- The Athletic 10/12

Rangers Rookie Brett Howden Tur...
- WFAN 10/12

Rangers reaction to first win p...
- New York Post 10/12

David Quinn picks up first Rang...
- New York Post 10/11

No goalie controversy here, des...
- The Athletic 10/11

How David Quinns tackling a per...
- New York Post 10/11

More news...
  NEXT GAMES
Sunday Feb 24th
12:30pm - Road

Wednesday Feb 27th
7:30pm - Home

Friday Mar 1st
7:00pm - Home

Sunday Mar 3rd
12:30pm - Home

Tuesday Mar 5th
8:30pm - Road

Thursday Mar 7th
7:30pm - Road

Saturday Mar 9th
7:00pm - Home

Monday Mar 11th
9:00pm - Road

Complete Schedule
  STANDINGS
  Team GP W L OT Pts  
  Lightning 54 39 11 4 82  
  Maple Leafs 53 33 17 3 69  
  Islanders 53 31 16 6 68  
  Canadiens 55 31 18 6 68  
  Bruins 54 29 17 8 66  
  Capitals 54 30 18 6 66  
  Blue Jackets 53 30 20 3 63  
  Penguins 54 28 19 7 63  
  Hurricanes 54 27 21 6 60  
  Sabres 53 26 20 7 59  
  Flyers 54 24 23 7 55  
  Rangers 53 23 22 8 54  
  Panthers 52 22 22 8 52  
  Red Wings 54 21 26 7 49  
  Devils 53 20 25 8 48  
  Senators 54 20 29 5 45  
FULL STANDINGS

About Us -  Site Map  -  Contact Us


?Copyright OutsideTheGarden.com 2001-19
This site and rolex replica uk it's content is in no way affiliated replica watches sale with, or representative rolex replica sale of the 
NHL
, NHLPA or the New York Rangers